Summerville has more good pizza than many people expect. You can grab an oversized New York slice downtown, sit down for a full Italian dinner in Oakbrook, or pick up a simple weeknight pie near Nexton.
Best local pizza spots in Summerville
Famulari’s Pizzeria in Oakbrook
Famulari’s works well for a classic pizza night when you also want a lively dining room. The Oakbrook location sits on Old Trolley Road and stays open later on Fridays and Saturdays, which helps when the night runs long.1 This is a solid choice for groups. One table can split a couple of pies, and nobody has to overthink it.
Sangaree Pizza on North Main Street
Sangaree Pizza offers dine-in, online ordering, and a comfortable spot for a meal that feels more like a sit-down dinner than a grab-and-go counter stop.2 This is a practical option for families because you can keep it simple with pizza, or branch out when someone at the table wants pasta.
D’Allesandro’s Pizza in Nexton
D’Allesandro’s in Nexton works well when you want a neighborhood pizza shop vibe with easy pickup. The restaurant describes a family-operated approach and highlights local ingredients on its location page.3 For many households near Nexton, this can be a dependable weeknight default. It also helps to know they advertise a daily military discount.3
Ebenezer Pizzeria on West Butternut Road
Ebenezer Pizzeria leans into a New England style approach. This is the sort of place many locals keep in rotation because it stays straightforward. You call, order, pick up, and the night moves on.
Benny Mazzetto’s in downtown Summerville
Benny Mazzetto’s is a strong pick for oversized New York style pies downtown. The restaurant highlights its grande 28 inch pizzas and lists the downtown Summerville address and hours on the location page.6 This is a smart option for feeding a crowd because one large pie can go a long way. It also fits well with a simple evening plan downtown, where you grab pizza and keep the rest of the night flexible.
Sabatino’s Authentic NYC Pizza in Summerville
Sabatino’s brings a Bronx-style New York pizza focus to Summerville, with dine-in and delivery options. Their Summerville page lists the Old Light Road address, phone number, and hours, which makes planning simple, especially around Sunday hours.7
This is a helpful option when you want a classic New York pizza: a foldable slice, a short wait, and a meal that does not require much coordination or thought.
A good pizza order comes down to a few choices that keep it tasting the way you want by the time you eat it. Think about how long it will sit in the box, whether you want crisp or chewy, and how adventurous your group really is. If the drive is longer, pick a style that stays sturdy, and don’t be afraid to give slices a quick blast of heat at home to bring the crust back. One dependable “everyone will eat it” pie also gives you room to try something bolder without risking the whole order.
References
- Famulari’s Pizzeria. (n.d.). Oakbrook. Retrieved February 14, 2026, from https://www.famularis.com/oakbrook
- Sangaree Pizza. (n.d.). Sangaree Pizza. Retrieved February 14, 2026, from https://sangaree-pizza.com/
- D’Allesandro’s Pizza. (n.d.). Nexton Square, Summerville. Retrieved February 14, 2026, from https://www.dalspizza.com/locations/nexton-square-summerville
- Uber Eats. (n.d.). D’Allesandro’s Pizza Nexton. Retrieved February 14, 2026, from https://www.ubereats.com/store/dallesandros-pizza-nexton/5dsZdd0PS9esKvOYOpagyw
- Ebenezer Pizzeria. (n.d.). Home. Retrieved February 14, 2026, from https://www.ebenezerpizzeria.com/
- Benny’s. (n.d.). Benny Mazzetto’s. Retrieved February 14, 2026, from https://www.bennysva.com/locations/benny-mazzettos/
- Sabatino’s Authentic NYC Pizza. (n.d.). Authentic New York pizza in Summerville, SC. Retrieved February 14, 2026, from https://www.sabatinosnypizza.com/summerville-ny-pizza
- King’s Pizza. (n.d.). King’s Pizza. Retrieved February 14, 2026, from https://www.kingspizza.co/
