New York Butcher Shoppe

The staff is super friendly and accommodating every time I walk in the door. Great quality kosher foods... bought a slice of NY cheesecake for my mom (the 3rd slice because it tastes great) and she found a piece of plastic in it and was so disappointed. I went in to convey to the staff - 1 person said they could probably do something about it but when I explained it again to the cashier, he asked if it was from the container - I wasn't sure. I later discovered from my mom it was plastic wrap; probably from slicing of the cake. At any rate, no offer to refund or replace; I bought another slice that day but it will be hard to patronize this business in the future for not making good on this mishap.

Knowledgeable and courteous staff, with solid recommendations; wide range of selections. Ordered a prime rib for six for Christmas dinner; we and our guests agreed it was outstanding - tender, well-marbled, delicious. In the past we have purchased fresh prime ribeye steaks, NY strips, and New Zealand Rack of Lamb (flash frozen), and have been 100% pleased with quality.

Love their banana pudding and the salmon they recommended. Will be continuing to come back here to try more selections. They also have specials and do meat packages that you can preorder and pick up later.

The store is a good store to buy meats, specialty items, and our favorite are the prepared meals. Though we have a request that you revisit the amount of salt being used...in particular this week's special, Beef Strognaoff, was over powering with a salt flavoring. Also we previously purchased the crab cakes on 2 occasions and enjoyed them but a couple of weeks ago, we made another purchase and they too were very salty. Please take these findings with an understanding that we enjoy visiting and making purchases of items in the "shoppe" and will do so again in the near future. Thank you.

On Jun 23, I ordered the roast chicken dinner from the Nexton shop. What I received was boiled chicken, not roasted. I stopped by to speak to the Mgr the next day. I was told it was his day off and he'd call the next day. I left my name and number along with pictures. As of today, Sunday, Jun 29, I still have not had any contact. So here is my review... Do not order roast chicken from this place. You will get boiled chicken. I was very upset and disappointed. Especially with no follow-up from Mgmt. I don't like leaving negative reviews, especially like this. I wasn't going to. I only wanted a conversation with the Mgr. However, the customer service follow-up is non-existent. The week before, I ordered the pot roast from the IOP NY Shop. It was very good and we enjoyed it very much. Nexton shop is a disappointment. I won't shop here.